Study: Broadband ‘black holes’ leave countryside far behind

Study: Broadband ‘black holes’ leave countryside far behind

Wednesday, 20 September, 2017

A study by the University of Aberdeen is calling for urgent action to connect people in rural areas with superfast broadband.

Academics studied postcode data from Ofcom which showed large swathes of the countryside struggle with shoddy average speeds less than 2.2Mbps.

In these broadband ‘black holes’ it would take around an hour and a half to download 1GB of data.

The paper was published in the Journal of Rural Studies.

Researchers say the lack of decent broadband is crippling rural businesses and putting families at risk of being left behind.

They are calling for Government to future proof rural broadband so the minority of the UK population who struggle with very slow internet speeds “are not cast adrift as the rest of the country gets faster and faster”.

Dr Lorna Philip, who co-authored the study, said the issues highlighted wider challenges for the government to prove it understood what the rural broadband could add to countryside communities.

As part of the Digital Economy Act 2017 the government has, together with BT, put forward a £600m plan for universal broadband but only at speeds of 10Mbps and only by 2020.

This broadband Universal Services Obligation (USO) has been heavily criticised as not ambitious enough, given that 95% of homes and businesses will have access to broadband speeds of 24Mbps or faster by the end of 2017.

Dodgy broadband could leave rural communities with potentially profound consequences including depopulation, the study says.

Study co-author Dr Caitlin Cottrill, said the more general move to ‘digital by default’ for shopping, banking, schoolwork and business was having a major negative effect in rural areas.

“If you’re in a remote area with poor digital connectivity this can have a detrimental impact, for example for farmers who need to submit animal registrations or single farm payment applications online, or school pupils who are disadvantaged because they cannot easily access online learning resources to complete their homework.”

While the study admits that community broadband schemes are helping to fill the gap, it says they can’t be the sole solution for decent rural internet.

“Our paper suggests that digital communications policy and regulation would benefit from digital future proofing, to ensure that any public sector market interventions in broadband infrastructure developments effectively address the digital divide,” they add.

Tom Rodgers author picture


Tom is a tech journalist and former Editor at

News What's the story?

Keep up with the latest developments in UK broadband.

The most complained about home broadband services

Who's failing to live up to expectations?

The most complained about home broadband servicesThe most complained about home broadband services Read more

Brits spend up to 4.9 hours surfing the web at work!

Over half describe themselves as “faffers”, wasting hours online during work.

Read more

Scottish government to pay for residents’ superfast broadband.

Missed fibre rollout target sees vouchers offered to connect everyone.

Read more

Beware of this Firefox security flaw!

Read more

Help Learn with us

Make the most of the internet with our broadband library.

What are the differences between HD, UHD, 4K and 8K?

What are the differences between HD, UHD, 4K and 8K?What are the differences between HD, UHD, 4K and 8K? Read more

How far can augmented reality take us?

Read more

Keeping the Internet of Things secure

Read more

The best broadband routers for 2020

Read more