Amazon’s facial recognition identifies US politicians as criminals

Monday, 30 July, 2018

We might believe all politicians are crooks, but it transpired Amazon’s controversial facial recognition system actually matched US Congressional politicians to mugshots of suspected criminals in a study conducted by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU).

The ACLU has long called for the banning of facial recognition use by police forces as it has proven to be unreliable at best and dangerous at its worst.

The ACLU stepped-up its campaign after it was revealed Amazon had been aggressively marketing its AI-powered Rekognition Service to police forces across the US. It had been touted as a way to identify people in real time from surveillance camera footage of from officers’ own body cameras.

In its latest testing Rekognition mistook images of 28 Congressional members for mugshots of criminal suspects. ACLU found the incorrect matches were biased towards black people, including six members of the Congressional Black Caucus. In all, 40% of the wrong matches were of people of colour.

ACLU’s test involved comparing images of every senator and representative, all 535 of them, against 25,000 publicly available mugshots of arrested Americans. The 28 mismatches represented a 5% error rate.

While this might sound a reasonable error rate, applied to thousands of faces taken from security and body cameras, that could be extrapolated to a large number of innocent people being wrongly identified.

Couple this with automated fines and punishments then an innocent person could soon find themselves entering a Kafkaesque world of mistaken identity.

Facial recognition technology in the hands of government is primed for abuse and raises significant civil rights concerns. It could allow, and in some cases has already enabled, police to determine who attends protests, continuously monitor immigrants and cities to routinely track their own residents, whether they have reason to suspect criminal activity or not.

- Jacob Snow: Attorney, ACLU

The ACLU has called for a moratorium to prohibit law enforcement agencies using facial recognition until further studies have been produced and Amazon has been more open about the system. Currently, it is not clear how the Rekognition system works particularly as Amazon has not disclosed how it tests for bias or accuracy.

Already a number of congress members have written to Amazon demanding a meeting to discuss in detail their Rekognition system.

In response, Amazon insisted that its system had been beneficial in preventing human trafficking, inhibiting child exploitation and reuniting missing people. With regard to ACLU’s latest survey, it said that at all times the system should be used in conjunction with human elements and acceptable thresholds should be set at 95% or higher.

Tim Bamford author picture


Tim is a veteran freelance journalist writing extensively on internet news and cybersecurity.

News What's the story?

Keep up with the latest developments in UK broadband.

The rise of cryptocurrency scams: don’t get mugged

The rising interest in Cryptocurrency is leaving consumers vulnerable to scams.

The rise of cryptocurrency scams: don’t get muggedThe rise of cryptocurrency scams: don’t get mugged Read more

Hyperoptic welcomes new investment from KKR.

Leading global investment firm acquires the majority stake of UK ISP Hyperoptic after they announce plans to quadruple fibre coverage.

Read more

Post Office officially the UK’s cheapest broadband deal

The latest victory in the price wars goes to Post Office with an amazing introductory offer for just over £15 a month!

Read more

Plusnet price hike warning

Incoming broadband and phone price rises before Christmas

Read more

Help Learn with us

Make the most of the internet with our broadband library.

Search engine alternatives to Google

Are there other options or is Google a search monopoly?

Search engine alternatives to GoogleSearch engine alternatives to Google Read more

The top online scams affecting Millenials – and how to avoid them!

Cybercrime is becoming more sophisticated every year - here are the current most frequent scams affecting millennials!

Read more

Is your faster broadband fast enough?

Read more

The differences between uploads and downloads

Read more